How to choose an AI SEO agency in India: 10 questions to ask
By Parul Potdar, Head of AI SEO
AI SEO pitches tend to sound alike. The difference shows when you ask for specifics: which questions they'll track, in which engines, on which pages, who does the work and what it costs. A good agency answers those plainly. A weak one goes back to "AI visibility" in general terms.
The 10 questions, and what good answers sound like
Send these to every agency you're considering and ask for written answers. Mark each one good, weak or missing, then compare.
| Question | A good answer | A weak answer |
|---|---|---|
| 1. What will you track, and how will we see it? | A fixed list of 20 to 50 questions your buyers ask, checked monthly in named engines, with dated screenshots, AI visits and enquiries by source | One "AI visibility score" from their own tool, with no questions or screenshots |
| 2. Can you show a named client in a dated AI answer? | The client, the question asked, the engine, the date and a screenshot, ideally with enquiries before and after | "Our clients see 300% more AI visibility", with no names, dates or engines |
| 3. How does this build on SEO? | It starts with technical SEO and your key pages, because AI answers draw on pages that search engines can crawl and trust | "SEO is dead, so we do AI SEO instead" |
| 4. Which engines, and why? | Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode first, then the assistants your buyers use, with a reason for each | "All of them", or a dozen engines and no reasons |
| 5. What happens in the first 90 days? | A month-by-month plan: audit and baseline, technical fixes, key pages rewritten, business details made consistent everywhere | "We'll start publishing content straight away" |
| 6. How do you earn mentions on other sites? | The sites that matter in your category, such as industry lists, directories and Indian publications, and how they'll earn a place on them | "50 backlinks a month", or posts about you on hundreds of sites |
| 7. Who works on our account? | Named people, their experience, and who you'll speak to each month | "A team of experts", and a salesperson you don't hear from again |
| 8. How do you handle the rules in our industry? | Knows your regulator, such as the NMC for clinics, MahaRERA for developers or SEBI for investment advice, and reviews every page before it goes live | For a clinic, suggests patient testimonials or before-and-after photos to build trust |
| 9. What do we own if we leave? | All content, data and reports. Search Console, Analytics and business profiles stay in your name | The agency holds the accounts, or the content lives on its platform |
| 10. How is the price worked out, and what's excluded? | A written scope tied to the fee, covering services, locations, content, engines tracked and PR, and saying whether GST, ad spend and tools are extra | A package name and a price, or a "guarantee" sold as an add-on |
How to check the answers
Ask to see the proof, then test it yourself. Run the client's question in the same engine. AI answers vary by day and by engine, so a monthly record of the same questions proves more than one screenshot. Ask whether they test in the apps people use or through an API: Surfer found only 4% overlap between the sources ChatGPT's API and its web interface cite (Surfer).
Check what they measure against what Google offers. Search Console's Generative AI performance report shows your impressions in AI Overviews and AI Mode by page (Google). Google's own guide warns against third-party tools that claim access to its internal metrics (Google), so be wary of an agency that says it can see more than that.
Check the engines are in proportion. Google still handles about 97% of searches in India (StatCounter, via Crimson Salt). An agency that talks only about ChatGPT is skipping most of your buyers. ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity matter too, so a good plan covers both and explains how it splits the work.
In a regulated industry, ask how they've handled your rules before. The NMC's October 2026 guidelines bar doctors from patient testimonials, fake or manipulated reviews, promotional before-and-after images, guarantees and unverifiable claims such as "best" or "No.1", and from paying anyone per patient. MahaRERA requires the registration number and a QR code in the top right corner of every project ad, including websites. A good agency builds these into its review step instead of leaving them to you. · /industries/real-estate-seo/
Red flags: when to walk away
- Guaranteed rankings, or guaranteed placement in ChatGPT or AI Overviews. No one controls what these engines say.
- A pitch built on one trick, such as an llms.txt file or special "AI schema". Google says Search ignores llms.txt files and that "there's no special schema.org markup you need to add" for its AI features (Google).
- AI SEO sold as a replacement for SEO. Google says its AI features are "rooted in our core Search ranking and quality systems".
- Paid reviews, fake mentions or bulk posts on low-quality sites. Google lists seeking "inauthentic" mentions among the things you don't need to do, and for clinics, fake, paid or manipulated reviews also break the NMC's guidelines.
- Reports you can't check: no questions, no dates, no screenshots, or a single score from a tool you can't see into.
- Accounts in the agency's name. If the agency owns your Search Console, Analytics or Google Business Profile, leaving gets hard.
- A long lock-in before you've seen anything. Ask what you'll have seen by the time you can leave, and what you keep if you do.
How to compare quotes
Quotes for AI SEO vary widely, because agencies sell very different work under the same name. A very low monthly fee usually buys a tracking tool, or an "AEO" line added to a basic SEO plan, not the technical work, content and PR that get a business cited.
Compare quotes on scope, not on the monthly figure: how many services and locations, how much content each month, how many questions and engines are tracked, and how much PR is included. Our pricing page explains what moves the price.
Questions about choosing an agency
Should we hire one agency for SEO and another for AI SEO?
Usually not. Most of the work overlaps and the same pages serve both, so splitting it can leave gaps, or two teams editing the same page. If you're happy with your SEO agency, ask whether it covers AI answers before adding a second one.
How long before we see results?
Plan for the first changes in AI answers around month three, once the technical fixes and key pages are done. Enquiries follow after that, at a pace that depends on your category and your competitors. Be wary of anyone who promises results in weeks.
Can we trust "best AI SEO agency in India" lists?
Use them to build a shortlist, not to decide. Check who published the list, because some are written by an agency that ranks itself first. Then ask everyone on it the same ten questions.
Can we do AI SEO in-house?
Yes, if someone on your team already does SEO well and has time for it every week. Tracking tools show where you're mentioned, but they don't fix pages or earn mentions. An agency makes most sense when you need technical work, content and PR at the same time.
Where this guide comes from
We're an AI SEO agency in Mumbai, so we have a stake in how you choose. These are the questions we'd want a client to ask us. Our answers to most of them are on our services, pricing and case studies pages. · /ai-seo-pricing/ · /case-studies/
Head of AI SEO
Heads our AI SEO work, from the free audits to the monthly SEO, AEO and GEO programme for every client, and writes our guides.
Put us through the same ten questions
Start with the free AI visibility audit. We'll check the searches that matter to you in Google AI Overviews, AI Mode, ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity, and show you who gets cited instead. Then ask us all ten questions.